Every large public offering leaves behind a crowd of disappointed applicants, and Coal India’s latest sale will be no exception. Anyone bidding for the Mahanadi Coalfields IPO should be prepared for the possibility of a nil result, because demand for well-known public sector names tends to run far ahead of supply. When the IPO allotment status appears after the issue closes, a good number of people will see a message saying nothing was allotted. Understanding why this happens helps investors set realistic expectations and avoid avoidable mistakes.
Table of Contents
The Simple Maths of Oversubscription
The most common reason for missing out would be oversubscription. The offer has 35% retail portion. If overall everyone applies for multiple times more than shares available in that portion then there are just not enough shares available. The registrar and exchange do a computerised lottery between all the valid applications. Only certain applicants get lucky and will get 1 lot.
Because of this, applying for multiple lots will not increase your chances of securing shares in the retail portion. All valid applicants get equal chance and so applying for more lots will not help. Many people fall into this trap.
Common Mistakes That Can Disqualify Your Bid
Another common reason people fail to secure shares is due to errors when applying.
Common errors include having a name mismatch between your PAN and demat account, having an inactive or incorrect UPI ID, and issues with linking your PAN to your bank account. Another common issue is having an unapproved mandate. When applying via UPI you have to approve the collect request in your payment app within the given timeframe. If you forget then your bid will not go through.
Applying multiple times with the same PAN is another common mistake. The exchanges will look out for this and if you do bid multiple times with the same PAN it may be cancelled. Everyone in your family should use their own PAN and demat account. Bidding below the lowest price in the price band can lead to your bid being disqualified.
Final Minute Bidding
Bidding at the last minute can be risky. Often platforms will run slowly on the final day due to high volumes causing timeouts. If your bid does not go through in time it will be lost completely. To avoid this apply on day 1 or 2 when the systems will be less busy.
Not having enough money in your bank account. You need the whole amount of the bid to be blocked so if you don’t have enough money the mandate will fail. Leave a little buffer in your bank.
Choosing The Right Bid
Many seasoned investors will bid at cut off price. This means you are happy with whatever price the shares are set to at the end of the bid. This means your bid will go through no matter what. This is a great option for retail investors and will ensure you don’t get disqualified due to bidding too low.
You also need to choose the right category to bid in. Retail investors need to ensure they do not exceed the maximum bid limit in that segment. If you do then your bid will be in a different category which will affect how the shares are allocated. This can reduce your chances of getting shares.
Accepting A Zero Outcome
Even if you complete your application perfectly you still may not get any shares. This is part of the process of a popular issue and does not reflect on your judgement. The logical thing to do would be not to panic buy the stock at any price once it has listed. If you truly believe in the business then evaluate it based on the same factors as before. Look at the earnings, dividends, debt and prospects of the sector.
You can also put yourself in a better position for next time. Ensure your PAN, bank and demat details are the same. Leave a buffer in your bank. Apply early and approve mandates as soon as possible.
